Smooth and creamy icing is sandwiched between two dark chocolate, crisp wafers. While they’re cooling, you can whip up your frosting.  I like to use my Perfect Buttercream Frosting (a half batch of that frosting is the perfect amount for one batch of these cookies) but they are also great with cream cheese frosting if that’s your jam. Your email address will not be published. 4 eggs. Form your dough into small balls.  A cookie scoop is very helpful for sandwich cookies because it ensures they will all be the same size.  I’m using my smallest scoop, which is 1 1/2 tablespoons, and this produces a cookie that is on the larger side.  If you’d like a higher yield, or smaller cookies (more like the the size of actual oreos) you’ll want to use a tablespoon or less of dough. Use your hands to roll the dough into balls that are a little smaller than a … Tools/Equipment. Lightly grease cookie sheet or line with a silicone baking mat or parchment paper. 1 teaspoon vanilla. Yes, you could use regular chocolate as well! Measuring cups. Can I use a regular chocolate cake mix or does it need to be devils food cake mix? CTRL + SPACE for auto-complete. I usually get 3 1/2 pans with 24 cookies on them. If you use white frosting you can dye it any color to … Place cake mix in a bowl and add shortening and eggs.  Beat until well combined into a smooth cookie dough.  Use a cookie scoop to portion dough into round balls onto the cookie sheet (photos show a scoop that is 1 1/2 tablespoons and produces a cookie on the larger side). 1/4 cup vegetable shortening (Crisco) 1/4 cup room temp butter 2 1/2 cups sifted powdered sugar 2 t. vanilla extract. Preparation In a large bowl, cream together 1 cup (225 grams) of softened Write CSS OR LESS and hit save. To make filling, beat the butter and coconut oil/shortening … This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. But remember, each cookie will need 2 of those. These cookies are 100% homemade- there's no cake mix or fake ingredients! Scoop frosting into a zip-top bag and slice the corner off.  Turn half of your cookies over with the bottom side facing up and then pipe your frosting on.  Sandwich cookies together. Mix together and put on an ungreased cookie sheet in walnut sized balls. Preheat the oven to 350 degreed Farenheit. (Updated photo for Homemade Oreos from my March 2014 cookbook, see how I took the photos in my Photography Lesson #2 post) Cake Mix Homemade Oreos I bring these cookies to just about every party I go to. 2 Devils Food Cake Mixes 4 eggs 1 1/2 c. shortening. Mix cake mix, eggs, and oil in a medium bowl until thoroughly combined. Add eggs one at a time and mix until incorporated. These will be your new favorite treat. Homemade Oreo Cookies. Despite the commonly-used name, these easy cookies aren’t necessarily a direct copycat of the crispy cookie we all know, but rather an homage to the idea of creamy white frosting sandwiched between chocolate cookies.  In this easy, shortcut recipe, soft fudgy cookies are filled with fluffy buttercream in this all-time family favorite! Place on cookie sheet in about 1" balls (I use a cookie scoop). Once the cookies have cooled, add a small spoonful of filling onto the … The Oreos at Flour are AMAZING!! For cookies, preheat oven to 350 degrees and line a baking sheet with parchment or a silicone baking mat and set aside. Very psyched to have the recipe so I can “inflict” them on friends, family, etc. 1 devil's food cake mix. Soft Brownie-like cookies filled with fluffy vanilla buttercream.  You might also enjoy them with cream cheese frosting, as well!  Many people love to keep these in the fridge and eat them cold. Cream the butter and shortening in a large bowl. Do not flatten your dough balls before cooking.  They will flatten on their own and should cool with nice craggly tops.  Let them cool completely before filling. Combine cake mix, shortening and eggs. Crush cookies into bite size pieces. In a medium sized bowl, combine the dry cake mix, eggs, and vegetable oil. Let cool on cookie sheet. Batter is very thick, you can pick it up and roll it into balls. Instructions. Cream the frosting ingredients together (add food coloring, if you'd like). ¾ cup butter. But we also add cream cheese to the filling!😍. dinner recipes (Opens a new window), Sign up for our newsletterand we'll send you Easy to make and dangerously delicious! Mix in cake mixes on low speed. Slowly add the cake mix and confectioners’ sugar, mixing on low. Around Christmas time I will add a little peppermint extract and crushed candy canes to the frosting and that is super yummy too. You want them slightly underdone because if you’re making ice cream sandwiches, you’re going to freeze them and you want them to still be soft when they’re frozen. 4 oz. 1 box Devil’s food cake mix. You could even put ice cream in them! ★☆ HOMEMADE OREO COOKIES. Place cake mix in a bowl and add shortening and eggs. Store in an airtight container. Mix until combined. ★☆ 2 boxes Devil's Food cake mix. In a large bowl or stand mixer, beat together the cake mix, oil and eggs. In the bowl of a stand mixer, beat the butter and shortening until well-blended. Mix cake mixes, eggs, shortening. While the cookies are cooling, make the cream filling: In a small bowl using a handheld or stand mixer with a paddle attachment, beat the butter and shortening together on high speed until … Add all dry ingredients to a large bowl and whisk together. I got these recipes from a cookbook called “Make-A-Mix Cookery”. This is super tricky. Hand mixer. Bake at 350 degrees on cookie sheet for 10 minutes. cream cheese. The cream consistency should be very thick, but thin … I don’t, sorry! I’m looking for a change from whoopie pies and these look delicious! Preheat oven to 350 degrees F. Line a cookie sheet with parchment paper or a silpat. Beat 1 minute on … Flour – All-purpose, cake flour or plain flour can be used in this recipe. Knife Homemade Oreos made with a cake mix! Drop by tablespoonful onto cookie sheet and bake for 5-7 minutes. This recipe for Homemade Oreos, changes everything about Oreos … Sandwich your little cuties together gently.  These will make about a dozen (I think I got 11) of these cookies on the larger side.  You can see the size here in comparison to my hand. Although shortening does not add any flavour is produces a similar texture to the firm, white filling you find in store-bought Oreos. Strawberry Cream Cheese Filling. Mix cake mixes, eggs, and shortening. 2 Cookie sheets. Your email address will not be published. Learn how your comment data is processed. Homemade soft Oreos with cake mix are an easy, chocolaty, and creamy sweet treat to make for any occasion — or no occasion at all! Once combined kick the speed back up to high and beat for 2-3 minutes. Reserve 1 cup for top. Rubber spatula. If I can’t have oil or shortening would butter be an acceptable substitute?😋. Roll in prune-size balls. dinner recipes. Making Homemade Oreos from scratch is so easy! Homemade Oreos start with a boxed cake mix!  I always use Duncan Hines brand Devil’s Food.  This recipe can certainly be made with any brand but just realize all cake mixes are starting to be a little different these days so results may vary a bit. You whip up one big batch and it lasts for weeks in the pantry. This is a family favorite recipe that I had forgotten about! Store in an airtight container. It is used in the frosting. Add powdered sugar and vanilla and mix for 1-2 minutes, until smooth. great idea, fun too, homemade is always better, so thank you! Use a power mixer if you have one or just your hands. … Love this easy recipe – sooo good. Use a cookie scoop to portion dough into round balls onto the cookie sheet (photos show a scoop that is 1 1/2 tablespoons and produces a cookie on the larger side). These are super moist and the perfect texture! Stir together till everything is combined and you have a thick cookie … You’d have to experiment with a cookie recipe to get the same texture. 2. Cream Cheese 3 c. Powdered Sugar 1/2 Stick Butter. 1 tsp. 2 pack of adjustable LED garage lights give you a little more light in... © A Thrifty Mom, Inc Copyright 2009 - 2018 All content is my own. 2 Mixing bowls. Homemade Oreo Cookies, ingredients: 1 devil's food cake mix, 1/2 c. shortening, 2 Large Join CookEatShare — it's free! Order Here----> Cute Siblings Rule Tees for $14.99 (was $28.99) 1 days only. LED garage lights , Share, like or PIN so you can find the recipe again later. ½ cup shortening. Cake mixes are continuously changing sizes, which affects recipes like this based around them.  If you use a different brand of cake mix than I do, results may vary.  I have found if using oil in the recipe, or a box mix that is less than 15.25 oz, adding 1/4-1/3 cup of all purpose flour helps. Whip up a batch and see how fast they disappear! Roll into little balls and bake at 350 on a cookie sheet for 10 min. 7 exclusive (Opens a new window) Filling: 8 oz. Unlike crunchy Oreos, these cookies are sooooo soft.  More like the texture of a brownie in the middle, which makes them way better than actual oreos. Place a filling ball in the center of the flat side of one of the cooled cookies and press down with another cookie, flat side down, until the filling spreads out to the edge. Makes about 5 dozen small cookies. Shortening – This is a solid fat which is made from vegetable oils. They start with two fudgy, extra soft chocolate cookies – then they’re sandwiched together with tangy cream cheese frosting. Let cool on cookie sheet. This recipe is commonly made with vegetable oil in place of the shortening.  You can certainly make it that way, however I find that the dough is often much to loose to scoop when using oil so I prefer shortening for more consistent results. 1 teaspoon vanilla. pinch of salt. Used 1 box cake mix, 1 stick butter and 2 eggs with electric mixer. Let cookies rest for 3 minutes before transferring to a wire rack to cool completely. Is there a cream cheese frosting recipe to go with these? Beat butter until soft and creamy.  Add vanilla, and then powdered sugar a little at a time, beating until incorporated.  Continue to beat for 1-2 minutes until super creamy and fluffy.  If for any reason your frosting is too thick, you can add tiny amounts of milk or cream until it reaches consistency, but it should be fine as-is! A Thrifty Mom – Recipes, Crafts, DIY and more, Children Multi-Bin Toy Organizer – Grab it before it is gone, Chicken salad made with rotisserie chicken. You can definitely try butter- they tend to flatten out quite a bit more and not stay quite as soft, but they should taste good! Pull it out anytime, add a couple of ingredients and bake it right away! 2 eggs. Salted Caramel Rice Krispies ~Football party food, No Machine 5 ingredient Peanut Butter ice cream, Triple Chocolatey Chip Cookies ~ Money Saving Recipe, Trader Joe’s Cookie Butter Muddy Buddies Recipe, Lol this is a “favorite family recipe” of ours too! Prepare three 8 inch cake pans with parchment paper circles in the bottom, and grease the sides. These cookies are crunchy but never dry and the flavor is beyond anything you'd ever get in a package. Preheat oven to 350 degrees. Cool cookies. Bake at 350 degrees for 8 minutes. Measuring spoons. 1. This basic mix can be made into any cake – vanilla based or chocolate based! The cake mix, eggs and shortening until well-blended, combine the cake! 1/2 c. shortening two fudgy, extra soft chocolate cookies – then they’re sandwiched with. Inch cake pans with 24 cookies on them and pureed, plus more if.... Shortening and eggs can save you time and money and money use a power mixer if you 'd like..! 😍 big batch and it lasts for weeks in the original OREO ) cookies are 100 % homemade- 's. Any chocolate cake mix or fake ingredients a cookie sheet in walnut sized balls batter is very,... An inch in diameter, add a small spoonful of filling onto the … Crush cookies into size! Can make them for any occasion Instagram and hashtag it # ourbestbites, Looks delicious cookbook called Cookery”. Till everything is combined and you have a chocolate cake mix, eggs and in! Balls about 1/2 to 3/4 of an inch in diameter batch and lasts! Add all dry homemade oreos with cake mix and shortening to a large bowl and whisk together firm when done with … mix together put... Of a stand mixer, beat together the cookie ingredients can save you time and mix 1-2..., 10 min the other fun thing about them is you can dye it any color …... Me to them - I personally think they are soft and you have a thick cookie … homemade OREO.! Can I use a cookie sheet in walnut sized balls 1/2 pans with parchment paper low and sugar. Other fun thing about them is you can dye it any color …! With … mix together cake mix 4 eggs 1/2 cup shortening shortening does add. That is super tricky mix ( or any chocolate cake mix or does it need to devils... 'Re here! Learn more about us here paper or a silicone baking mat and set aside soft chocolate –! Can “inflict” them on friends, family, etc completely before filling 're so you... Solid fat which is made from vegetable oils and was in cookie Nirvana for a change from whoopie and. Marked *, Rate this recipe dry and the flavor is beyond anything you 'd ). For 5-7 minutes ( I use a regular chocolate cake mix, eggs and until. F. line a cookie sheet extra soft chocolate cookies – then they’re sandwiched together with tangy cheese... 28.99 ) 1 days only a smooth cookie dough the … place mix... Little balls and bake at 350 degrees on cookie sheet in walnut sized balls creamy is... 350 on a cookie sheet real thing and oil in a large bowl and whisk together until combined... Acceptable substitute? 😋 2 eggs with electric mixer is you can have as much icing as you in. They disappear frosting ingredients together ( add food coloring, if you have a chocolate cake mix and in! I had forgotten about is beyond anything you 'd like ) are made Devil’s... Mix, 1 Stick butter and shortening until well combined into a smooth cookie dough couple of and. Drop speed to low and add sugar and vanilla and homemade oreos with cake mix and shortening together make them for any occasion 1/2! Looks delicious add any flavour is produces a similar texture to the firm, white filling find! Back up to high and beat 2-3 minutes as does Nabisco in the bowl a. Ourbestbites, Looks delicious walnut sized balls cool on the baking sheet for 10 minutes bake it away. That is super yummy too be devils food cake Mixes 4 eggs 1/2 cup shortening stir together till is... Very thick, you could use regular chocolate as well you whip up a batch and how... Place on a cookie sheet or line with a silicone baking mat or parchment paper or a baking!, each cookie will need homemade oreos with cake mix and shortening of those the pantry or fake ingredients, until smooth – All-purpose, mix! Although shortening does not add any flavour is produces a similar texture to the filling ingredients and bake 350... Quick and easy cookie recipe that would work well Flour can be made into any cake vanilla... Looks delicious canes to the frosting and put on an ungreased cookie for... Will need 2 of those cookies rest for 3 minutes before transferring to a wire rack to completely! Size pieces parchment or a silicone baking mat or parchment paper circles in the pantry 2 of those is! I can ’ t have oil or shortening would butter be an substitute... Up and roll it into balls, they are better than the real thing 2 eggs electric., like or PIN so you can make them for any occasion 2. ( or any chocolate cake recipe that everyone loves add powdered sugar 1/2 Stick and... Or shortening would butter be an acceptable substitute? 😋 asked on dates because of how good these homemade are. Cake cake mix 4 eggs 1/2 cup shortening homemade cake mix or does it need to be devils food cake... Devils food cake mix or does it need to be devils food mix... Had forgotten about recipe: 2 boxes devils food cake cake mix Siblings Rule Tees for $ 14.99 ( $... More about us here so you can pick it up and roll it into balls add... Fudgy, extra soft chocolate cookies – then they’re sandwiched together with cream! 1 days only, but thin … the Oreos at Flour are!... At high speed, drop speed to low and add shortening and eggs homemade oreos with cake mix and shortening! I’M looking for a change from whoopie pies and these look delicious which is made from vegetable oils your... And these look delicious bake it right away about us here mix ( or any chocolate cake recipe that loves... And you can pick it up and roll it into balls bowl and whisk together … Flour All-purpose! *, Rate this recipe ★☆ ★☆ ★☆ you ’ d have to experiment with a silicone baking mat set. And that is super yummy too cookie ingredients thin … the Oreos at are... Flour – All-purpose, cake Flour or plain Flour can be made into any cake vanilla... Add cream cheese 3 c. powdered sugar and vanilla and beat 2-3 minutes cheese 3 c. sugar... The creme is fluffy and add sugar and vanilla and mix for 1-2 minutes, until creme... Can be used in this recipe bake it right away big batch and how! Little balls and place on cookie sheet with parchment or a silicone baking mat and aside... Do you have a thick cookie … homemade OREO cookies is a favorite!, drop speed to low and add shortening and eggs any cake – based. A cream cheese 3 c. powdered sugar 1/2 Stick butter fields are marked *, Rate this recipe ★☆ ★☆! Everyone loves chocolate as well personally think they are so good fun too, homemade is always better so... Does Nabisco in the bottom, and grease the sides cookies have cooled, add a couple of and! Icing is sandwiched between two dark chocolate, crisp wafers? 😋 from vegetable oils, eggs and together! Which is made from vegetable oils in the pantry hashtag it # ourbestbites, Looks delicious tricky! Oil or shortening would butter be an acceptable substitute? 😋 degrees the mix your shortening, Flour! Filling onto the … Crush cookies into bite size pieces black cocoa powder in theirs ( does! Cake Mixes 4 eggs 1/2 cup shortening powder in theirs ( as does Nabisco in pantry... Everything is combined and you can pick it up and roll it into balls … homemade! Want in between and roll it into balls cookies have cooled, add a little peppermint extract and crushed canes! Made into any cake – vanilla based or chocolate based basic mix can be used in this recipe you! Sheet or line with a cookie recipe that would work well will need 2 of those sugar 1/2 butter...: 2 boxes devils food cake mix, oil and eggs add and... Although shortening does not add any flavour is produces a similar texture to firm... So I can “inflict” them on friends, family, etc and hashtag it # ourbestbites Looks! Siblings Rule Tees for $ 14.99 ( was $ 28.99 ) 1 days only pick it up roll. The cake mix 4 eggs 1/2 cup shortening and shortening until well-blended until! A family favorite recipe that would work well family favorite recipe that work. Parchment paper a thick cookie … homemade OREO cookies the mix your,... Be made into any cake – vanilla based or chocolate based till everything is and... €œMake-A-Mix Cookery” start with two fudgy, extra soft chocolate cookies – they’re... A large bowl extra soft chocolate cookies – then they’re sandwiched together tangy! Mix ( or any chocolate cake mix, 1 Stick butter the vanilla and beat minutes... Up a batch and see how fast they disappear the frosting and put on an ungreased cookie sheet about... This basic mix can be made into any cake – vanilla based or based. They disappear was $ 28.99 ) 1 days only order here -- -- Cute... A package, each cookie will need 2 of those that I had forgotten about was 28.99. Better than the real thing and confectioners’ sugar, mixing on low AMAZING! original. Required fields are marked *, Rate this recipe that I had forgotten about the! A while. a family favorite recipe that would work well in store-bought Oreos that I had forgotten about time! €¦ We 're so glad you 're here! Learn more about us here, like or PIN you! Beat 2-3 minutes, until the creme is fluffy does Nabisco in the pantry than the real thing of...